Skip to main content

Best cherry pie in Indian Lake, NY.

Delicious Cherry Pie at Blue Mountain Lake's Best Diner
Cherry Pie: A Sweet Finish to Your Meal

Cherry Pie: A Sweet Finish to Your Meal

Indulge in our homemade cherry pie. Made with ripe cherries and flaky crust, it's a diner classic. Savor a slice with a scoop of vanilla ice cream or a dollop of whipped cream. Our cherry pie is a must-try for breakfast or dessert at our American cafe.
Convenient Delivery and Pickup Options for Your Favorites

Convenient Delivery and Pickup Options for Your Favorites

Craving diner classics? Enjoy our cherry pie, pancakes, and burgers from the comfort of your home with our convenient delivery and pickup options. Order online for a quick pickup or have your favorites delivered straight to your door.

Our location

Map showing the location of Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner on 8814 NY-30 in Blue Mountain Lake

Loading today's hours...