Sundaes
$7.95
Two scoops with two toppings, whipped cream, nuts, and a cherry.
“Fun vibes, friendly service and yummy eats. Really liked the seasonings and tons of sweets options - cake, pie, ice cream and cinnamon rolls. Can't wait to come back!”
Sweet desserts at Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner in Indian Lake, NY include cakes and ice cream, with pickup available for your order.
Order onlineSundaes
$7.95
Two scoops with two toppings, whipped cream, nuts, and a cherry.
“Fun vibes, friendly service and yummy eats. Really liked the seasonings and tons of sweets options - cake, pie, ice cream and cinnamon rolls. Can't wait to come back!”
Banana Split
$10.95
Three scoops with banana, two toppings, whipped cream, nuts, and a cherry.
“We went for breakfast for my 70th birthday this morning, absolutely delicious. Chef Darrell came over to our table, we asked him if he was open for dinner, he said what time do you want to eat, even though he wasn't open. We showed up at 5 & he was waiting for us. He absolutely made my day with the most delicious dinner & dessert. We left feeling like part of his family. Thank you Chef you are an amazing person & Chef. We love you & will see you soon.”
Ice-cream cones
$4.95+
Ice cream in a cone comes in small or large, with optional toppings.
“Great food, especially the desserts, in a beautifully restored Silk City. Chef Darrell himself was very friendly. I'd highly recommend this place.”
Ice-cream cups
$4.50+
Ice cream served in a cup, with small or large sizing.
“What a great spot in the mountains! The quiche, “special Salad,” blt, and ice cream were amazing!”
Pecan Pie
$9.95
Pecan-filled pie with a sweet, set custard filling.
“Chef Darrell's has vibes for days!!!!!!!!!!! Chicest diner car I've ever seen and the food was absolutely amazing. I had country fried steak and pecan pie. So good. Can't wait for a chance to go back. ♥️♥️♥️”
Apple, Blueberry or Cherry Pie
$7.95
Choose apple, blueberry, or cherry pie for a fruit-filled dessert.
“What a hidden gem! The food was fresh and made in house. Everything had that home cooked feel. The Reuben was excellent and the tart cherry pie was perfect.”
Carrot Cake
$8.95
Baked cake featuring carrots, served as a dessert.
“Did not sit and eat but picked up food to go. Chef Darrell was sitting outside and met him. What a pleasant guy and as nice as could be! Good luck to him, food was great had a turkey club, generous amount of French fries, couldn't eat them all! Good salad and great carrot cake! Don't pass this place by, next time I'll come and sit to enjoy a meal!”
Cheese Cake
$8.95
Creamy, tangy cheesecake served as a dessert.
“When I went searching for a nice place halfway between Pleasant Valley and home, I was delighted to find a bright and cheerful diner. The fish and chips came with an excellent tartar sauce. My granddaughter was tired from a week at camp and didn't have an appetite. She had a cup of chamomile tea and nibbled a little bit of my dinner, and left with a very fine cheesecake. Five minutes out she was fast asleep in the car.”
At Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner, you can have desserts such as fruit pies, carrot cake, chocolate lava cake and cheesecake. Apple and blueberry meet in cobbler, while pecans feature in a pie.
Banana Split has three scoops, banana, two toppings, whipped cream, nuts and cherry. Sundaes pair two scoops with two toppings. Ice-cream cones come in small or large, with chocolate sauce as an option.
Visit Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner in Indian Lake, NY for pickup or dine-in. Ice-cream cups come in small or large sizes, with optional caramel sauce, chocolate sprinkles or rainbow sprinkles.
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.