Ice Cream in Indian Lake

Ice cream with sweet sauces and sprinkles awaits at Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner in Indian Lake, NY, with pickup available.

Order online

Ice Cream to Try

Banana Split

$10.95

Three scoops with banana, two toppings, whipped cream, nuts, and a cherry.

“Chef Darrell greets you at the door with a smile. You can’t miss him. Don’t miss Chef Darrell’s diner in Blue Mountain Lake either. Finding fault with the food or service is like looking for a flaw in the Hope Diamond. Enjoy his deck and dine al fresco. Home cooking by the man himself. Graduate of Culinary Institute and the food will pass any test. Skillet specials will hold you for the day. His ice cream is great too. Music soundtrack not your usual elevator music. Great place! Drive a little, eat a lot!”

Ice-cream cones

$4.95+

Ice cream in a cone comes in small or large, with optional toppings.

“What a great spot in the mountains! The quiche, “special Salad,” blt, and ice cream were amazing!”

Ice-cream cups

$4.50+

Ice cream served in a cup, with small or large sizing.

“Great Ruben, Fish and chips, chicken and waffle. Friendly staff, and Darell was great to speak with. Great strawberry ice cream. If ever driving by deffinetly stop here for a meal you will enjoy, or just stop for dessert.”

Sundaes

$7.95

Two scoops with two toppings, whipped cream, nuts, and a cherry.

Made with Care at Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner

At Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner, ice cream comes with topping choices such as caramel sauce and rainbow sprinkles. You can also add chocolate sauce to your dessert alongside one of the sprinkle options.

Choose small or large sizes for Ice-cream cones and Ice-cream cups. Your Banana Split comes with three scoops, banana and two toppings, finished with whipped cream, nuts and a cherry on top.

Visit us at Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner in Indian Lake, NY for pickup or dine-in. Sundaes feature two scoops of ice cream and two toppings, finished with whipped cream, nuts and a cherry.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular ice cream options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Sundaes — Choose two toppings—caramel or chocolate sauce, chocolate or rainbow sprinkles—over two scoops with whipped cream, nuts, and a cherry.