Sandwiches in Indian Lake

French fries accompany many sandwiches at Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner in Indian Lake, NY, with pickup available for your meal.

Order online

Sandwiches to Try

Breakfast Sandwich

Eggs and cheese on a Kaiser roll with your choice of meat.

Bacon Breakfast Sandwich$8.50Eggs and cheese with bacon on a kaiser roll make this a classic breakfast sandwich.
Sausage Breakfast Sandwich$8.50Eggs and cheese with sausage on a kaiser roll make this a hearty breakfast sandwich.
Ham Breakfast Sandwich$8.50Eggs and cheese with ham on a kaiser roll make this savory breakfast sandwich.

“Had heard how great this place was and had to try it, and it did not disappoint! Breakfast sandwich was absolutely delicious! Service was great!! Looking forward to coming back again!!”

“Stumbled across this place and so happy that we did! Everything was fabulous. Breakfast sandwich that was loaded with eggs and ham and a Ruben that was overflowing with hunks of the most tender corned beef! Plus get the grilled cinnamon roll! It's amazing! Will definitely be back!”

Chicken Sandwich

Chicken sandwich, fried or grilled, served with French fries.

“We had there homemade deep fried breaded chicken breast sandwich. It was very good. Also the portion size was quite large served with fries. Would go back again”

Open Face Roast Turkey or Grilled Beef

An open-faced sandwich lets you choose turkey or grilled beef, with fries.

“After a morning of hiking, we stopped at Chef Darrell's and it was a great surprise. The food was GREAT. In fact, my open-face turkey sandwich was probably the best I have ever eaten! If you are looking for great food in Blue Mountain Lake, be sure to give Chef Darrell's a try. You will not be disappointed.”

“Can you say YUM?! Stop here for breakfast, lunch, dinner or a treat. You will never go away hungry and Chef Darrell is awesome. Open face turkey is the bomb. Great food, great staff! Better get ya some of that!”

Half Sandwich

Half sandwich with a choice of ham, turkey, or tuna, plus soup and fries.

Tuna Melt Sandwich

$16.95

Tuna and melted cheese in a hot sandwich, served with fries.

“Chef Darrell is an amazing chef and owner of this North Country eatery just outside of Blue Mountain Lake on Route 30. We enjoyed a cheeseburger and a tuna melt with fries. He even came out from his kitchen to say Hi to his diners! Clean, friendly and good food 👍”

Turkey Club

$15.95

Turkey club sandwich served with French fries.

“What a place, I'm so happy to have them in this beautiful area. I had the reuben sandwich, it was to die for. As a snobby New Yorker who has had many life-changing sandwiches, I can say that this one was up there. My wife had the turkey club and loved it as well. Fast service, lots of seating outside, this is an all around great spot, no notes! Thanks Chef Darrell!”

Two-Fisted Reuben Sandwich

$16.95

Corned beef, Swiss, sauerkraut, and dressing in rye bread, with fries.

“Mr Darrell, we need to talk. The reuben, the cinnamon bun, the egg breakfast; delicious. I might be biased from camping food for the weekend. But when the menu is a single page, you know it will be👌 Thanks for the great company when things slow down in the kitchen. We will be back.”

BLT Sandwich

$15.95

Bacon, lettuce, and tomato fill this sandwich, served with French fries.

“What a great spot in the mountains! The quiche, “special Salad,” blt, and ice cream were amazing!”

French Dip Panini

$17.95

Roast beef fills a pressed panini, served with French fries.

“A not so hidden gem in the ADK! Constant turnover of diners, friendly and fast service. Chef Darrell himself took our order as it got very busy just after we arrived. We didn't really look at the day's specials, but the regular menu is pretty varied. I enjoyed my French dip sandwich and lemonade. Reasonably priced for an independent restaurant in a seasonal area.”

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

$12.95

Melted cheese between grilled bread is served with French fries.

“First time visitor and very impressed with everything. Cool building with friendly staff and great quality food. Had the pouttine skillet and it was very tasty. Wife ordered a griiled cheese sandwich and it was perfect.”

Turkey and Cheese Panini

$16.95

Turkey and cheese in a pressed sandwich, served with fries.

“Superb sandwiches”

Fried Fish Sandwich

$16.95

Fried fish sandwich served with french fries on the side.

Kids Grilled Cheese

$12.95

Grilled cheese comes with French fries and your choice of drink.

Veggie Flat Bread

$16.95

Flatbread with portabella, spinach, roasted peppers, mozzarella, and fries.

Made with Care at Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner

Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner serves sandwiches in open-face, panini, club, and melt styles. Your choices include roast turkey or grilled beef, tuna melts, fried fish, and turkey with cheese.

Breakfast Sandwich has eggs and cheese on a kaiser roll with bacon, ham, or sausage. Chicken Sandwich comes fried or grilled with french fries; Half Sandwich includes ham, turkey, or tuna and a cup of soup.

Visit us in Indian Lake, NY for pickup or dine-in. Kids Grilled Cheese includes french fries and a beverage, with chocolate milk, apple juice, or cocoa among the drink choices for your child's meal.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular sandwiches options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Breakfast Sandwich — Eggs and cheese fill a Kaiser roll, with a required choice of bacon, ham, or sausage; gluten-free preparation is optional.
Two-Fisted Reuben Sandwich — A Reuben layers corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and dressing in rye bread, with French fries on the side.
Veggie Flat Bread — Portabella mushrooms, spinach, roasted red peppers, and mozzarella top the flatbread; fries are served alongside, with gluten-free preparation available.
Turkey Club — This layered turkey sandwich comes with French fries; a gluten-free preparation is available as an optional customization.
Kids Grilled Cheese — This kids' meal includes a grilled cheese sandwich, French fries, and one required choice of beverage.