Skip to main content
Grilled Cinnamon Roll

Diner in Indian Lake

Sweet breakfasts and savory sandwiches anchor the diner choices at Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner in Indian Lake, NY for pickup.

Order online

Breakfast

Eggs Benedict

$15.95

Poached eggs and Canadian bacon top an English muffin with hollandaise.

“One thing I love when traveling is trying out local diners. Chef Darrell's Mountain Diner was above and beyond what I even thought was possible. I spent the weekend in the area recently and had the best Eggs Benedict for my birthday. I loved the atmosphere and the owner came out and mingled with customer's and was very welcoming!!!! Very neat story behind the diner itself. 10/10 incredible establishment 👏”

Lunch

Quiche of the Day

$14.95

A savory quiche served with a seasonal tossed salad.

“We discovered Chef Darrell's Mountain Diner yesterday when out garage saleing yesterday! WOW!! The quiche of the day way fantastic, service was great (even though they were short staffed), Chef was friendly and very personable. Just an all around great experience. I can't wait to go back.”

Sandwiches

Burgers

Cheeseburger

$14.95

A cheeseburger is served with French fries on the side.

“We were visiting from Albany, NY - looking for someplace for our family to dine. This showed up in our search and so we decided to give Chef Darrell a try. Not disappointed. Food was delicious. Mom & husband had the Fried Chicken, my sons both had burgers and i had the open Turkey sandwich. Portions were great. Turkey gravy was definitely homemade. Darrell was constantly coming out to welcome everyone and knew several regulars by name. Plan on going back in the morning for breakfast which i am sure will be great as well.”

Chicken

Salads

Caesar Salad

$7.50+

Choose a small or large Caesar salad, with optional proteins available.

“For the BEST food in Blue Mountain Lake, NY, two words, Chef Darrell's! We ordered take out: Sheperd's pie, meatloaf, chicken potpie, beef stew - ending the delicious meals with luscious apple/blueberry pie. Don't walk --> run to this picturesque, hometown diner. You will not be disappointed. Just look at my mom's plate and she is quite picky. Thank you, chef Darrell!”

Fries

Desserts

Apple Blueberry Cobbler

$8.95

Baked apples and blueberries sit beneath a tender cobbler topping.

“This is an exceptional diner both in atmosphere and quality of food. They have a wonderful menu and an awesome mix between comfort and refinement with the items they have on both the regular menu and the specials. Everything was good, but the chicken and waffles were absolutely insane. The most tender piece of fried chicken I’ve had on light fluffy waffles.”

Carrot Cake

$8.95

Baked cake featuring carrots, served as a dessert.

“Did not sit and eat but picked up food to go. Chef Darrell was sitting outside and met him. What a pleasant guy and as nice as could be! Good luck to him, food was great had a turkey club, generous amount of French fries, couldn't eat them all! Good salad and great carrot cake! Don't pass this place by, next time I'll come and sit to enjoy a meal!”

Cheese Cake

$8.95

Creamy, tangy cheesecake served as a dessert.

“When I went searching for a nice place halfway between Pleasant Valley and home, I was delighted to find a bright and cheerful diner. The fish and chips came with an excellent tartar sauce. My granddaughter was tired from a week at camp and didn't have an appetite. She had a cup of chamomile tea and nibbled a little bit of my dinner, and left with a very fine cheesecake. Five minutes out she was fast asleep in the car.”

Eggs Benedict

Made with Care at Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner

Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner serves diner dishes from poached eggs with hollandaise to a wrap with grilled steak, onions and blue cheese. You can also finish with apple and blueberry cobbler.

Stuffed French Toast offers cheesecake filling; Blue Mountain Pancakes come in a full stack with optional chocolate chips. Chicken Tenders arrive with french fries and your choice of honey mustard or BBQ sauce.

Visit us in Indian Lake, NY for pickup or dine-in. Banana Split comes with three scoops, banana, two toppings, whipped cream, nuts and a cherry; chocolate and caramel sauces are topping options.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular diner options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

  • Fish and Chips Lunch — This lunch serves fried fish with French fries, the two components commonly associated with fish and chips.
  • Breakfast Sandwich — Eggs and cheese fill a Kaiser roll, with a required choice of bacon, ham, or sausage; gluten-free preparation is optional.
  • Two-Fisted Reuben Sandwich — A Reuben layers corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and dressing in rye bread, with French fries on the side.
  • Eggs Benedict — Two poached eggs with Canadian bacon and hollandaise come with home fries; a gluten-free modification is available.
  • Turkey Club — This layered turkey sandwich comes with French fries; a gluten-free preparation is available as an optional customization.